Recommended Posts

  • Replies 125
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Posted

Ted; Your Radicals for Happiness posts are always fun to look at. Best Wishes! Chris Grieb

Posted

Beethoven's Ode to Freedom (the 4th movement of his 9th symphony), according to Rand, this music is malevolent. Some malevolent! What the dickens was Rand thinking?

Ba'al Chatzaf

Posted
Thanks, Chris. Funny, Peter. Bob, you never commented on this post.

Beethoven.jpg

That scene from Soylent Green cut me to the quick. It so happens that Edward G. Robinson was a dying man when he shot that scene. He expired shortly after -Soylent Green- was in the can. Call me an eco-phreak, if you must, but I shed a tear for the late great Planet Earth and Robinson's death scene got to me.

As to Beethoven's music, it was bombastic, but not malevolent. I just don't understand what Ayn Rand had in mind. If Beethoven was not a happy scout, recall:

1. He was brutalized by hist drunken father, both physically and psychologically.

2. He went deaf. There is no worse fate than that for a musician and a composer.

3. He had the care of his nephew who was a no-good bum.

Is it any wonder that Beethoven scowled?

Ba'al Chatzaf

Posted
Thanks, Chris. Funny, Peter. Bob, you never commented on this post.

Beethoven.jpg

That scene from Soylent Green cut me to the quick. It so happens that Edward G. Robinson was a dying man when he shot that scene. He expired shortly after -Soylent Green- was in the can. Call me an eco-phreak, if you must, but I shed a tear for the late great Planet Earth and Robinson's death scene got to me.

As to Beethoven's music, it was bombastic, but not malevolent. I just don't understand what Ayn Rand had in mind. If Beethoven was not a happy scout, recall:

1. He was brutalized by hist drunken father, both physically and psychologically.

2. He went deaf. There is no worse fate than that for a musician and a composer.

3. He had the care of his nephew who was a no-good bum.

Is it any wonder that Beethoven scowled?

Ba'al Chatzaf

I knew about Robinson's dying of cancer as they filmed Soylent. One of my favorite movies, very, very well done. I will eventually write an article on it alone.

As for Beethoven, he could certainly be heavy and dark. Fate knocking on the door in The Fifth is not exactly cheerful. Nor the second movement of The Ninth. But "malevolent" is simply silly. She simply didn't like something about him, and so used that word which would rationalize her judgement. I will take Beethoven's "malevolence" over Mozart's treacle any day.

Just think, could Alexander de Large have been brainwashed to Tschaikovski?

As for "malevolence" - I love Siegfried's Funeral March, Night on Bald Mountain, Also Sprach Zarathustra - Dawn, Right of Spring, Carmina Burana - O, Fortuna. It's all lovely heavy metal to my ears.

Posted
Thanks, Chris. Funny, Peter. Bob, you never commented on this post.

Beethoven.jpg

That scene from Soylent Green cut me to the quick. It so happens that Edward G. Robinson was a dying man when he shot that scene. He expired shortly after -Soylent Green- was in the can. Call me an eco-phreak, if you must, but I shed a tear for the late great Planet Earth and Robinson's death scene got to me.

As to Beethoven's music, it was bombastic, but not malevolent. I just don't understand what Ayn Rand had in mind. If Beethoven was not a happy scout, recall:

1. He was brutalized by hist drunken father, both physically and psychologically.

2. He went deaf. There is no worse fate than that for a musician and a composer.

3. He had the care of his nephew who was a no-good bum.

Is it any wonder that Beethoven scowled?

Ba'al Chatzaf

I knew about Robinson's dying of cancer as they filmed Soylent. One of my favorite movies, very, very well done. I will eventually write an article on it alone.

As for Beethoven, he could certainly be heavy and dark. Fate knocking on the door in The Fifth is not exactly cheerful. Nor the second movement of The Ninth. But "malevolent" is simply silly. She simply didn't like something about him, and so used that word which would rationalize her judgement. I will take Beethoven's "malevolence" over Mozart's treacle any day.

Just think, could Alexander de Large have been brainwashed to Tschaikovski?

As for "malevolence" - I love Siegfried's Funeral March, Night on Bald Mountain, Also Sprach Zarathustra - Dawn, Right of Spring, Carmina Burana - O, Fortuna. It's all lovely heavy metal to my ears.

Ted -

I've never thought I had a good understanding of Rand's condemnation of Beethoven. She stated that he was a very talented composer, though she abhorred his sense of life. I just don't perceive a malovelent sense of life in his work.

Perhaps Barbara B. can lend some insight on the connection Rand made.

Bill P

Posted
As for Beethoven, he could certainly be heavy and dark. Fate knocking on the door in The Fifth is not exactly cheerful. Nor the second movement of The Ninth. But "malevolent" is simply silly. She simply didn't like something about him, and so used that word which would rationalize her judgement. I will take Beethoven's "malevolence" over Mozart's treacle any day.

Mozart's treacle?! You're as big a musical philistine as Rand herself... Did you ever listen to his piano concerto KV 488? (see for example

) (2nd movement), the pianoconcerto KV 466 or the concerto KV 491? The piano sonata KV 310? (see for example
(1st movement). The Fantasie KV 475? (see for example
). The Ave Verum Corpus?
Posted
As for Beethoven, he could certainly be heavy and dark. Fate knocking on the door in The Fifth is not exactly cheerful. Nor the second movement of The Ninth. But "malevolent" is simply silly. She simply didn't like something about him, and so used that word which would rationalize her judgement. I will take Beethoven's "malevolence" over Mozart's treacle any day.

Mozart's treacle?! You're as big a musical philistine as Rand herself... Did you ever listen to his piano concerto KV 488? (see for example

) (2nd movement), the pianoconcerto KV 466 or the concerto KV 491? The piano sonata KV 310? (see for example
(1st movement). The Fantasie KV 475? (see for example
). The Ave Verum Corpus?

Sorry, I did listen, and I can't say those peices did anything for me. I think Mozart vs Beethoven may be genetic, like Cat vs Dog. I did love Amadeus. I rushed out and bought some Mozart. I found out that all the good bits had already been used in the movie.

Treacle has its uses. I love pecan pie. Just because I don't find that I can enjoy something doesn't mean that I think others a wrong to do so.

And I invite you to post your recommendations at Radicals for Happiness.

Anyone who is interested in doing so should send me their email address thru OL.

Posted
Sorry, I did listen, and I can't say those peices did anything for me.

Ok (although I find it difficult to imagine that such music can leave someone cold), but that isn't the same as saying that it's treacle, as that description certainly doesn't fit those pieces.

And I invite you to post your recommendations at Radicals for Happiness.

Well, thanks for the invitation, but I don't feel comfortable with giving that kind of more or less official recommendations. If I mention one thing I feel I must mention many other things as well, complete with arguments, and I just don't have the time to do that.

Posted
Thanks, Chris. Funny, Peter. Bob, you never commented on this post.

Beethoven.jpg

That scene from Soylent Green cut me to the quick. It so happens that Edward G. Robinson was a dying man when he shot that scene. He expired shortly after -Soylent Green- was in the can. Call me an eco-phreak, if you must, but I shed a tear for the late great Planet Earth and Robinson's death scene got to me.

As to Beethoven's music, it was bombastic, but not malevolent. I just don't understand what Ayn Rand had in mind. If Beethoven was not a happy scout, recall:

1. He was brutalized by hist drunken father, both physically and psychologically.

2. He went deaf. There is no worse fate than that for a musician and a composer.

3. He had the care of his nephew who was a no-good bum.

Is it any wonder that Beethoven scowled?

Ba'al Chatzaf

I knew about Robinson's dying of cancer as they filmed Soylent. One of my favorite movies, very, very well done. I will eventually write an article on it alone.

As for Beethoven, he could certainly be heavy and dark. Fate knocking on the door in The Fifth is not exactly cheerful. Nor the second movement of The Ninth. But "malevolent" is simply silly. She simply didn't like something about him, and so used that word which would rationalize her judgement. I will take Beethoven's "malevolence" over Mozart's treacle any day.

Just think, could Alexander de Large have been brainwashed to Tschaikovski?

As for "malevolence" - I love Siegfried's Funeral March, Night on Bald Mountain, Also Sprach Zarathustra - Dawn, Right of Spring, Carmina Burana - O, Fortuna. It's all lovely heavy metal to my ears.

Ted -

I've never thought I had a good understanding of Rand's condemnation of Beethoven. She stated that he was a very talented composer, though she abhorred his sense of life. I just don't perceive a malovelent sense of life in his work.

Perhaps Barbara B. can lend some insight on the connection Rand made.

I just read through Passion and The Objectivist this week, but found no help.

  • 7 months later...
Posted
Posted

Ted: "I've never thought I had a good understanding of Rand's condemnation of Beethoven. She stated that he was a very talented composer, though she abhorred his sense of life. I just don't perceive a malovelent sense of life in his work.

Perhaps Barbara B. can lend some insight on the connection Rand made."

Sorry. I've never had the least idea why Rand saw Beethoven as malevolent. I do know that she had heard very little of his work. My only guess is that she listened to a composition -- or part of a composition-- that was dark and gloomy. and assumed that the part gave her sufficient information about the total. I have seen her doing the equivalent successfully in the area of philosophy, that is, learning an aspect of a thinker's views and extrapolating the essence of his overall philosophy from that. aspect. It sometimes works with philosophies. It rarely works with music.

Barbara.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now