Ayn Rand’s Thoughts on Israel

[Ed Hudgins]

Ayn Rand’s Thoughts on Israel
By Edward Hudgins

May 12, 2016 -- On the anniversary of Israel's founding on May 14 1948, we can turn to Ayn Rand for insights about why such an economically successful state with an open society is so hated by its neighbors.

East-West conflict and Israel

In 1974, Ayn Rand was asked about American Middle East policy in the aftermath of the Arab-Israeli War of the previous year. That was the fourth war since the modern state of Israel was established in 1948. It was the fourth time that the little country had had to fight for its existence.

While Rand did not advocate sending American troops into the conflict, she did argue that America should “Give all the help possible to Israel.” She stated specifically that “the help Israel needs is technology and military weapons—and they need them desperately. Why should we help Israel?” She explained that at that time, Israel was “fighting not just the Arabs but Soviet Russia, who is sending the Arabs armaments.”

The Soviet Union, of course, has since collapsed. But there was more to Rand’s argument, because she asked, “Why are the Arabs against Israel?”

 

Premodern vs. Modern Arab-Israeli culture clash

“The Arabs are one of the least developed cultures,” Rand argued. “They are typically nomads. Their culture is primitive, and they resent Israel because it's the sole beachhead of modern science and civilization on their continent.”

Of course, most Arabs even then weren’t nomads. Indeed, a millennium ago Baghdad and Cairo were major urban centers. But the deeper point was that in modern times Arabs have had a pre-modern culture and world view, especially compared to the Jews who had emigrated from Europe (Continue reading here.)

[BaalChatzaf]

3 hours ago, Ed Hudgins said:

Ayn Rand’s Thoughts on Israel
By Edward Hudgins

May 12, 2016 -- On the anniversary of Israel's founding on May 14 1948, we can turn to Ayn Rand for insights about why such an economically successful state with an open society is so hated by its neighbors.

East-West conflict and Israel

In 1974, Ayn Rand was asked about American Middle East policy in the aftermath of the Arab-Israeli War of the previous year. That was the fourth war since the modern state of Israel was established in 1948. It was the fourth time that the little country had had to fight for its existence.

While Rand did not advocate sending American troops into the conflict, she did argue that America should “Give all the help possible to Israel.” She stated specifically that “the help Israel needs is technology and military weapons—and they need them desperately. Why should we help Israel?” She explained that at that time, Israel was “fighting not just the Arabs but Soviet Russia, who is sending the Arabs armaments.”

The Soviet Union, of course, has since collapsed. But there was more to Rand’s argument, because she asked, “Why are the Arabs against Israel?”

 

Premodern vs. Modern Arab-Israeli culture clash

“The Arabs are one of the least developed cultures,” Rand argued. “They are typically nomads. Their culture is primitive, and they resent Israel because it's the sole beachhead of modern science and civilization on their continent.”

Of course, most Arabs even then weren’t nomads. Indeed, a millennium ago Baghdad and Cairo were major urban centers. But the deeper point was that in modern times Arabs have had a pre-modern culture and world view, especially compared to the Jews who had emigrated from Europe (Continue reading here.)

Rand's mastery of historical detail  was not up to par.  

[Ed Hudgins]

To be fair, I also had a quote where she said she didn't have detailed knowledge of some of the history.

[BaalChatzaf]

25 minutes ago, Ed Hudgins said:

To be fair, I also had a quote where she said she didn't have detailed knowledge of some of the history.

Did she have a detailed knowledge of any of the history?

 

[anthony]

2 hours ago, BaalChatzaf said:

Rand's mastery of historical detail  was not up to par.  

Of what detail, exactly? Granted she was often superficial in her international knowledge, but she had the basics right, here. It is well documented that European Jews who early purchased land and settled in Palestine were educated sophisticates, like West colliding with East, relative to the local Arabs. It started badly and got worse. (By about 1900 there were already 70,000 Jews there under the Ottoman Empire).