Sign in to follow this  
RohinGupta

Analyzing Maslow's model of motivation from the perspective of Objectivism

Recommended Posts

Maslow’s theory of motivation claims that first motivators are physiological factors like food, shelter, etc., after that safety factors like rule of law and insurance(protection in general), then meaningful social relationships, then social status and reputation, and finally an individual’s need to find himself or herself. The final one being self-actualization.

From OEFO perspective, not a chosen few, but all adults are or should be motivated by self-actualization (OEFO refers to my book “Organizational Ethics from Objectivism”, from which the snippet is taken). The Central Purpose of Life (CPL) in Objectivist Ethics is quite similar to the concept of self-actualization. Other needs in Maslow’s model, ranging from physiological, safety-related, social, and emotional should be inferred and adjusted based on the CPL. For example, a CEO of an organizations will need a bigger social circle than a scientist(generally speaking), since the latter focuses more on in-depth study, and the former more on collaborative actions for building products and services. Safety is a negative factor and should not be the primary motivation. E.g., retiring early without having any clear CPL is not right. Also, the emotional part of the self should be fuelled using art or sports, such that one is sufficiently motivated to move towards their CPL. The same criteria is true for personal and other relationships. The contribution of each relationship towards the CPL should be evaluated.

True, there are adults who have very destructive CPLs. Communism in Soviet Russia and elsewhere, Socialism in Nazi Germany, or many Socialist intellectuals and politicians of the Indian Left are a few of the examples of those having destructive CPLs. Also, among millennials, the non-productive purpose of enjoying as an ultimate end is popular. However, this too is not right as a Central Virtue, because it’s not derived from the Virtue of Productivity: The creation of products and services as a priority. These CPLs can be contrasted from the CPLs of Steve Jobs, Bill Gates 1.0, the founding fathers of America, Walt Disney, Narendra Modi, etc. Overall, irrespective of the value or the disvalue of CPL, the fact remains that humans are, or should be motivated by purpose.
 
 

Maslow's-Model.png

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

A more elaborate explanation is here

https://medium.com/@rohingupta2k18/reinventing-maslows-model-of-motivation-5cdc0d173caf?fbclid=IwAR1A2QxMa6NfYpUeu_zkYQJPbPtDnWIdKzl5szrk3aTXobSQD3FQEiL97Yc

P.S: The Maslow's model of motivation is widely quoted in many influential books of management. I use Objectivist Ethics, concept of Central Purpose of Life in particular, to improve the model and its application.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Qua life the central purpose of life is life--that is, the propagating of one's DNA. Qua life this is axiomatic.

Safety, negative or not, is l likely the first operative step in securing the organism.

Maslow's ideas are a hodgepodge.

Everybody is motivated by a purpose, even not to have a purpose. That can be a plus or a negative. Or purposes. This can be quite complicated. For instance, the purpose of envy appeasement. Someone who is extremely productive can be a grovelling, ignorant controlled coward.

One can be immune to envy but not realise he's living in a sea of envy the creatures of which are out to get him.

Explications on CPL with no mention of envy is pure intellectualization.

--Brant

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
3 hours ago, Brant Gaede said:

Qua life the central purpose of life is life--that is, the propagating of one's DNA. Qua life this is axiomatic.

Safety, negative or not, is l likely the first operative step in securing the organism.

Maslow's ideas are a hodgepodge.

Everybody is motivated by a purpose, even not to have a purpose. That can be a plus or a negative. Or purposes. This can be quite complicated. For instance, the purpose of envy appeasement. Someone who is extremely productive can be a grovelling, ignorant controlled coward.

One can be immune to envy but not realise he's living in a sea of envy the creatures of which are out to get him.

Explications on CPL with no mention of envy is pure intellectualization.

--Brant

Please differentiate between civilized humans and animals.

Also, some of your answers are in the blog. Hint - Productiveness as the core.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
8 hours ago, RohinGupta said:

Please differentiate between civilized humans and animals.

Also, some of your answers are in the blog. Hint - Productiveness as the core.

Ah, the animals. After we separate them from us where do we put them?

--Brant

where do we put us?

Rand was so oblivious to envy I don't think she ever explicated on it, but Toohey's character came close

envy was here a shorthand for psychology generally through egregious example

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Hi All,

        I am in middle of converting the content of blog into video.

       Please check the first draft of part of video and share feedback.

                          

 

      Pending : Voice over and parts explaining values, Central Purpose of Life, and Alternative model.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Final draft of video

It captures the essential concepts involved in Human Motivation, introduces the most popular model for motivating humans, identifies the gaps in that model and fixes them.

So checkout the video and share the feedback here or in Youtube. Hope its useful...!

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7lmHBjgSSHI

P.S: The ideas are derived from Central Principles of Objectivist Ethics

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
Sign in to follow this