nationalism What to learn about Russian goals when you don't really care [updated]
Entry posted by william.scherk
6,232 views
One of the items I fish out of the general Russia Russia Russia hoopla is geopolitical strategy. In other words, setting aside the unproven allegations of the Trump-Russia 'collusion' grab-bag, and putting to one side the actual details of the "Russia hack" of the 2016 US presidential election -- leaving the residual "what is this administration's larger strategy with regard to Russia, its hopes and fears, its ambitions."
This is no easy task. The election campaign revealed just a few rules of thumb that a Trump administration would use in a new relationship.
Each of us will have an impression of just what President Trump hopes to achieve in relation to Russia between now and 2020. For me, having studied utterances of Michael Flynn and the many Russia/Putin statements from the president, it is to "get along," to cooperate where it serves American interests, and perhaps to let Russia back in from the cold by removing sanctions where appropriate. In an sense, it is a desire to move the 'deep state' off its suspicious foundations in order to make a better partnership with the Eurasian nuclear power.
(the 'deep state' I envision as the intersection of established policy [of the executive branch, including national security agencies] and law [from the legislature]; it is the entrenched state of affairs, the 'ship of state' -- a vehicle of praxis built up over time. The 'deep state' of course takes its orders not from a shadowy cartel, but from department policy as written, intelligence findings as transmitted, and law. Law as in the welter of official acts and regulations, eg, Magnitsky-related sanctions. The 'deep state' vehicle can be refitted and given new missions, but this takes time, time to install new commanders with clear mission statements, time to legislate and decree a change in direction, speed, goal and targets)
Having established their own briefs on facts and values, strategy and intelligence, law and practice, OLers might like me might have asked themselves the same set of questions -- not of the American 'vehicle' commanded by President Trump, but of the Russian ship of state.
What Russia wants.
-- that boring introduction done, here is a well-written analysis of Russian imperatives:
Russia’s Evolving Grand Eurasia Strategy: Will It Work?
NB: at 4200 words the article is not light reading. But I suspect readers will be better able to answer the question "What is a proper Russia policy for the USA?"
One person whose opinions I wish we could consult right now is the founder of Objectivism. Having a cold eye on the Soviet Union, a cold eye for any unfree state, a cold eye for dictatorships, Ayn Rand would likely be able to add moral clarity to the 'debates' about Russia Russia Russia.
A couple of folks here have contended that Rand would be enamored of Donald Trump, a notion I find preposterous. But I could be very wrong.
[Spelling and grammar plotzes fixed Jan 10, 2018]
191 Comments
Recommended Comments
Posted by william.scherk,
March 29, 2019: "President Donald Trump's national security advisers spent months trying to convince him to sign off on a plan to supply new U.S. weapons to Ukraine to aid in the country's fight against Russian-backed separatists, according to multiple senior administration officials."
Recommended by william.scherk
0 reactions
Go to this comment
Posted by Jon Letendre,
Sometimes misunderstandings have fruitful consequences
Recommended by william.scherk
0 reactions
Go to this comment
Posted by Jon Letendre,
Not quite sure how, where or when the member fell off the Syria bus, but hey.
Recommended by william.scherk
1 reaction
Go to this comment
Posted by Jon Letendre,
"The histrionics are not feigned."
Recommended by william.scherk
0 reactions
Go to this comment
Posted by tmj,
Clear concepts, strong argument?
Recommended by william.scherk
0 reactions
Go to this comment
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now