Jump to content


The "real" Aristotle vs the received Aristotle

  • Please log in to reply
No replies to this topic

#1 BaalChatzaf



  • Members
  • 12,572 posts
  • Gender:Male
  • Location:Currently residing in New Jersey, the Bad-a-Bing State.
  • Interests:mathematics, physics, alternative energy sources.

    I am also involved in preparing recorded books for blind and dyslexic folks.

Posted 29 December 2011 - 09:40 AM

We know that only a portion of the works of Aristotle survived even into the Middle Ages. We have second hand comments of works of Aristotle that we no longer can access.For exampleCicero spoke of Aristotelian dialogues which were on a par with those of his mentor Plato. Even so,we cannot take these second hand comments as canonical.

So,as a practical matter we must accept the received Aristotle as the only Aristotle we can be sure about. We are stuck with his Cliff Notes ™. Most likely these were transcribed from his lectures by his teaching assistants.The Aristotle I reference is the same (received) Aristotle that Ayn Rand learned.

It is absolutely useless to speculate what the "real" Aristotle "really"thought. That is lost to us,and barring a very unlikely and lucky break such as the one that revealedArchimedes -Method- to us,it is not going to get any better.

For future reference, any comment I make about Aristotle is about the received Aristotle,the only one we have to hand.In so far as we have reference to his works (partial as they may be)the indications are that the lessons retained from Aristotle on motion are WRONG. The writings given to us are a mistaken,WRONG theory of matter and motion.It is unfortunate for the world that this is the lesson that was carried on for over a thousand years.Progress in the natural sciences was inhibited by the received Aristotle and his enthralled followers. It was not until the late 17th century c.e.that the last dregs and dross of Aristotelian teachings on motion were purged from natural science.Free at last!

Ba'al Chatzaf
אויב מיין באָבע האט בייצים זי וואָלט זיין מיין זיידע

0 user(s) are reading this topic

0 members, 0 guests, 0 anonymous users